Abba-Zaba [57g] - USA
$2.25
Shop USA Chocolate  Abba-Zaba are taffy candy bars with peanut butter centers, made by the Annabelle Candy Company in...
Airheads - Blue Raspberry  [16g] - USA
$0.75
Shop Airheads - Blue Raspberry  AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting...
Airheads - Cherry [16g] - USA
$0.75
Shop Airheads - Cherry  AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with...
Airheads - Grape [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads - Grape AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with...
Airheads - Green Apple [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads - Green Apple AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with...
Airheads - Orange [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads - Orange AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with...
Airheads - Strawberry [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads - Strawberry AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with tangy...
Airheads - Watermelon  [16g] - USA
$0.75
Shop Airheads - Watermelon AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting with...
Airheads - White Mystery  [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads - White Mystery  AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting...
Airheads Big Bar - Blue Raspberry & Cherry [42.5g]- USA
$2.75
Shop Airheads-Big Bar Blue Raspberry & Cherry AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting...
Airheads Big Bar - Strawberry & Watermelon [42.5g] - USA
Sold Out
Shop Airheads-Big Bar Strawberry & watermelon AirHeads  candy bars are  known for their chewy taffy-like candy  texture that is bursting...
Assorted Gumballs [500g]
$8.75
Shop Gumball  Assorted gumball Net Weight [500g]
Astro Pop - Original [32g] - USA
$4.25
Shop Astropop  Shop for Nostalgic & Retro  candy. Blast from the past. Astropop candy Original were first  made...
Atomic Fireball
Sold Out
Net Weight 8g
Beemans Gum
$1.75
Shop Beemans Gum Nostalgia  
Big Hunk [56g] US
$2.50
Shop Big Hunk  Big Hunk is a bar of roasted peanuts covered in chewy honey-sweetened nougat. Net Weight [56g]
Black Jack Gum [25g] - USA
$1.75
Shop Black Jack Gum  Shop for Nostalgic gum, Retro Candy! Black Jack is back it's an animated Flavored gum....
Boston Baked Beans Theater Box [135g]-US
$3.50
Shop Boston Baked Beans Theater Box Boston Baked Beans are one of the oldest – and tastiest – peanut...
Broadway Rolls Strawberry
$2.75
Net Weight 60g
Candy Mix Cassette Tape Tin [36.8g]
$7.00
Shop Candy Mix Cassette Tape  The Vintage cassette shaped tin is filled with sweet cherry mini cassette candies. Net Weight: [36.8g]
Candy Necklace [21g] - USA
$1.00
Shop Candy Necklace Wear these candy necklaces for a sweet look! Your friends will love to get this jewelry gift...
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
$2.75
Chewy, flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since its...
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
$2.75
Chewy, flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since its...
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
$2.75
Chewy, flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston Chew an American favorite since its...
Charleston Chew - Vanilla Theater Box [113g]- US
$4.00
Shop Charleston Chew - Vanilla Theater Box Chewy, flavored nougat wrapped in a rich, chocolaty coating have made Charleston...
Charms Assorted Squares [28.3g] USA
$2.75
Shop Charms Assorted Squares Shop NOSTALGIC CANDY CANDY ! Charms Assorted Squares come in a Square shaped assorted Fruit...
Chewy Red Hots Intense Cinnamon Theater box [142g]-US
Sold Out
Shop Chewy Red Hots Intense Cinnamon   Net Weight[142g]
Chocolate Buds [500g]
$8.00
Net Weight 500g
Choward's Guava Mints
Sold Out
Net Weight 24.8g
Choward's Lemon Mints
$2.00
Net Weight 24.8g
Choward's Scented Gum
$2.25
Net Weight 8g
Choward's Violet Mints
$2.00
Net Weight 24.8g
Clark Bar
Sold Out
Clark isn't the average candy you share with your grandmother. Made with real chocolate and real peanut butter, Clark Bar is...
Clove Gum
$1.75
Nostalgia  
Cow Tales - Brownie
$1.00
Net Weight 28g
Cow Tales - Vanilla
$1.00
Net Weight 28g
Dubble Bubble Twist Wrap [500g]
$6.75
Net Weight 500g
Fruit Stripe - Juicy
$3.25
Net Weight 58g
Gerrit's Quality Belgian Chocolate Sticks [25g] - US
$3.50
 Shop Gerrit's Quality Belgian Chocolate Sticks Feeling Nostalgic? Do you want to buy some Retro Candy? Well you...
Gillam Old Fashion 5 pk Candy Stick
$4.25
Net Weight: 71g
Good & Plenty Licorice Candy Theater Box [170g]- US
$4.50
Shop Good & Plenty Licorice Candy Theater Box Shop for Retro Classic old Fashioned Candy ! Do you Reminisce...
Good & Plenty Licorice Candy [500g]
$9.75
Net Weight 500g
Hershey's 5th Avenue
$3.75
Keep a big stash of the hard-to-find bar that’s been a favorite of chocolate and peanut butter fans...
Hershey's Whatchamacallit
$2.25
When your hunger calls for chewy caramel, rich chocolate, and peanut flavor, grab a Whatchamacallit Bar! It’s not...
Hershey's Whozeewhatzit KING [73g]
$5.00
It's a chocolatey crisp and peanut butter candy bar - Net Weight: 1.6oz (45g)
Hershey's Whozeewhatzit [48g]
$2.50
It's a chocolatey crisp and peanut butter candy bar - Net Weight: 1.6oz (45g)
La Pipette Black Licorice Pipe Wrapped
Sold Out
Net Weight 18g
Laffy Taffy - Banana
$2.00
Net Weight 42.5g
Abba-Zaba [57g] - USA
$2.25
Airheads - Blue Raspberry  [16g] - USA
$0.75
Airheads - Cherry [16g] - USA
$0.75
Airheads - Grape [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Airheads - Green Apple [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Airheads - Orange [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Airheads - Strawberry [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Airheads - Watermelon  [16g] - USA
$0.75
Airheads - White Mystery  [16g] - USA
Sold Out
Airheads Big Bar - Blue Raspberry & Cherry [42.5g]- USA
$2.75
Airheads Big Bar - Strawberry & Watermelon [42.5g] - USA
Sold Out
Assorted Gumballs [500g]
$8.75
Astro Pop - Original [32g] - USA
$4.25
Atomic Fireball
Sold Out
Beemans Gum
$1.75
Big Hunk [56g] US
$2.50
Black Jack Gum [25g] - USA
$1.75
Boston Baked Beans Theater Box [135g]-US
$3.50
Broadway Rolls Strawberry
$2.75
Candy Mix Cassette Tape Tin [36.8g]
$7.00
Candy Necklace [21g] - USA
$1.00
Charleston Chew - Chocolate
$2.75
Charleston Chew - Strawberry
$2.75
Charleston Chew - Vanilla
$2.75
Charleston Chew - Vanilla Theater Box [113g]- US
$4.00
Charms Assorted Squares [28.3g] USA
$2.75
Chewy Red Hots Intense Cinnamon Theater box [142g]-US
Sold Out
Chocolate Buds [500g]
$8.00
Choward's Guava Mints
Sold Out
Choward's Lemon Mints
$2.00
Choward's Scented Gum
$2.25
Choward's Violet Mints
$2.00
Clark Bar
Sold Out
Clove Gum
$1.75
Cow Tales - Brownie
$1.00
Cow Tales - Vanilla
$1.00
Dubble Bubble Twist Wrap [500g]
$6.75
Fruit Stripe - Juicy
$3.25
Gerrit's Quality Belgian Chocolate Sticks [25g] - US
$3.50
Gillam Old Fashion 5 pk Candy Stick
$4.25
Good & Plenty Licorice Candy Theater Box [170g]- US
$4.50
Good & Plenty Licorice Candy [500g]
$9.75
Hershey's 5th Avenue
$3.75
Hershey's Whatchamacallit
$2.25
Hershey's Whozeewhatzit KING [73g]
$5.00
Hershey's Whozeewhatzit [48g]
$2.50
La Pipette Black Licorice Pipe Wrapped
Sold Out
Laffy Taffy - Banana
$2.00
Spinner